SharePositive Discipline for Teenagers: Chapters 1-3
Over the next few weeks, I’ll be diving into Positive Discipline for Teenagers by Jane Nelsen and Lynn Lott on the Joyful Courage podcast, offering a deep dive into the principles behind this parenting approach. We’ll be exploring how Positive Discipline can help us navigate the messy, wonderful teen years with a focus on…
…connection, respect, and autonomy.
For those unfamiliar, Positive Discipline is a parenting method that emphasizes mutual respect, kindness, and collaboration. Instead of relying on punishment, Positive Discipline teaches kids important life skills like self-discipline, responsibility, and problem-solving. And when it comes to teens, the approach adapts to encourage independence while maintaining guidance. It’s all about helping our kids thrive emotionally and behaviorally while empowering them to make their own decisions.
I will explore how Positive Discipline shifts as our kids grow into teens, with a focus on building strong connections, fostering independence, and guiding them toward emotional regulation and decision-making.
Chapter 1: How Do You Know When Your Child Becomes a Teen?
Let’s dive into Chapter 1, titled How Do You Know When Your Child Becomes a Teen? This chapter sets the stage for the entire book and offers a big-picture look at adolescence. It’s not about a specific moment or age when your child becomes a teenager. Instead, it’s about a shift — in both your child’s development and your relationship with them.
One of the key takeaways here is that adolescence isn’t a test of your parenting skills. It’s a natural stage of human development — a long transition that we experience alongside our kids. This period is all about brain rewiring and identity exploration. The transition to adulthood is messy, and no matter how well we parented in the early years, this change will still happen.
The chapter invites us to think about how we’re feeling during this time. Are you suddenly more anxious about what your teen is doing? Are they asking for more freedom, and you’re not sure how to manage it? Are you noticing your child becoming more emotionally volatile or pulling away from you, closing their bedroom door and seeking more independence?
It’s in these moments that we realize the level of control we once had is a thing of the past. Our kids are growing, and they’re going to start making choices for themselves, whether we’re ready or not. And that’s what this chapter is all about — welcoming the messy, beautiful transition of adolescence.
A major theme in this chapter is teen brain development, which is happening regardless of what kind of parenting you’ve done up until now. Jane Nelsen and Lynn Lott do a great job of breaking down the changes in the teen brain in a way that’s practical and easy to understand. You’ll see the overlap with Dr. Daniel Siegel’s work on brain development in adolescence, but without the heavy scientific language. The authors explore the teen’s need to individuate, which is their developmental task of figuring out who they are separate from the family. This can feel like rebellion — and it’s easy to react with fear or resistance.
But remember, rebellion isn’t necessarily a sign of failure. It’s a natural part of the process, even though it may feel overwhelming.
Ultimately, Chapter 1 reminds us that adolescence is a time of growth and transformation, and it’s okay if it feels challenging. It’s all part of the journey, and understanding what’s happening can help us respond with more empathy and patience.
Chapter 2: Whose Side Are You On?
In Chapter 2, we shift from observing our teens’ transition to adolescence to understanding how they experience us during this time. Both we and our teens are in transition, and how our kids perceive us during this phase is crucial.
The chapter emphasizes staying curious about our teen’s perspective. While we often focus on our reactions to their behavior, it’s important to recognize that they are reacting to us as well. Their emotional world is influenced by how we show up for them, creating a cycle of responses. This cycle can escalate, so being mindful of how we react is key.
Since their brains are still developing — particularly the frontal lobe, which controls decision-making — teens often process emotions impulsively.
This can make things messy. The chapter helps us understand that what seems like rebellion is really a natural process called individuation, where teens try to establish their identity outside of the family. This may feel like defiance, but it’s a critical part of their development.
The authors also remind us that both parents and teens live in separate realities. Both perspectives are valid, and recognizing this is crucial for maintaining empathy. By acknowledging their emotions as legitimate, we can approach our teens with respect and understanding, making the process less confrontational.
Connection is the chapter’s core theme. It stresses that the best way to help our teens through adolescence and life’s ups and downs is through strong, supportive connections. This connection helps them navigate not only teenagehood but also adulthood.
Here are some practical tips for building that connection:
- Getting into our kids’ shoes — Try to see the world through their eyes.
- Listening and being curious — Approach their experience with curiosity rather than judgment.
- Choosing your child over external pressures — Focus on what’s best for your child, not what others think.
- Replacing humiliation as encouragement — Help your child feel supported, not embarrassed.
- Making sure the message of love gets through — Do they know you have their back?
- Involving your teen in problem-solving — Let them have a say in finding solutions.
- Making respectful agreements — Collaborate on decisions, rather than imposing rules.
A key takeaway is that change requires practice. Parenting teens is a learning process, and flexibility is essential. You may need to adjust your approach for each child. The focus should always be on connection, trust, and support, even when things get challenging. Fear and worry may push us to control, but the more we focus on empathy and connection, the easier this transition will be for everyone.
Chapter 3: What is Your Parenting Style?
In Chapter 3, we dive deep into parenting styles and how they shape our relationship with our teens. Understanding our style can either encourage or discourage our teens, and how we approach parenting matters greatly in this stage of development.
The chapter highlights four key parenting styles:
- The Brick (Rigid/Authoritarian): This style is controlling, with a “my way or the highway” approach. Often, it can lead to rebellion or people-pleasing, and may delay a teen’s individuation — their process of figuring out who they are. Teens raised this way may struggle to explore their true selves.
- The Rug (Permissive): Overprotective, permissive parents can lead to entitlement, fragility, and a lack of responsibility. When everything is done for the child, they don’t develop life skills and may rely on others to take care of them, creating dependency.
- The Ghost (Neglectful/Absent): This style often results from personal struggles or overwhelming circumstances, causing a parent to be distracted or disengaged. Over time, this can lead to feelings of neglect, lack of self-worth, and a search for belonging outside the family. Teens may even take on parental roles, which can hinder their own development.
- The Positive Discipline Way (Kind and Firm): The ideal style for fostering growth in teens. This approach combines both kindness and firmness, teaching teens that freedom comes with responsibility. It also emphasizes mutual respect, accountability, and learning from mistakes, all in a supportive environment without blame or shame.
The chapter emphasizes that the pendulum often swings between rigid and permissive parenting styles, depending on our emotional state. This reactive approach is common, but the goal is to pause, reflect, and choose a more thoughtful response. The Positive Discipline approach helps us balance empathy and authority, guiding teens through challenges with respect and consistency. It’s all about being Kind and Firm at the same time.
The book also provides effective skills to help parents shift to this style, focusing on understanding the need for change, learning new strategies, and letting go of control. Letting go can be scary, especially when teens are engaging in risky behavior, but shifting from control to influence is key.
An important reminder: even kids raised with Positive Discipline will rebel. It’s part of their growth process.
As the book states, children raised democratically and respectfully are often more confident in taking risks, rebelling, and learning from their experiences. This is a sign that they are developing self-awareness, critical thinking, and independence — all valuable life skills.
Final Thoughts
Parenting is one of the most important, rewarding, and sometimes challenging journeys we’ll ever embark on. As we continue exploring Positive Discipline for Teenagers, we’ll revisit the core ideas of connection, respect, and growth time and time again. So, if you haven’t already, get your hands on a copy of the book! You can grab it directly from positivediscipline.com, Amazon, or your local bookstore — or even check it out at your library.
From Joyful Courage Episode 564: Positive Discipline for Teens Part One – Transitioning into Adolescence
Looking for parent coaching? Casey offers private coaching services. See more info here.
Comments